Home Arts & LifeIndependent Games Festival Jurors Refuse to Vote for Games that Use AI

Independent Games Festival Jurors Refuse to Vote for Games that Use AI

The move forces game developers to reflect on their AI usage in the aftermath of the decision

by Chris Harrison

A promotional image from the game Big Walk that shows several characters on rocks on a beach
Screencapture of the video game BIG WALK (courtesy of House House)

Listen to the whole story here:

A statement from 19 Independent Games Festival (IGF) jurors sent ripples throughout the game development world because of their decision not to vote for any game using Generative AI. The awards have been around since 1998, and the jurors’ statement includes a list of reasons they feel using GenAI in game development is harmful. 

The group says the statement was spurred on by a “significant increase in the number of submitted games developed with generative AI tools,” which caused “some fairly intense discussion and disagreement across the judge and jury pools.” The statement wasn’t signed by every festival juror.

Much of the controversy was centered around the game Big Walk, which was found to have used Large Language Models (LLMs) for a small amount of coding, according to reporting from Polygon. Big Walk is a presumed game of the year candidate at many awards shows. Now, their candidacy may be in doubt if other jurors follow suit.

House House, the game’s developers, have since issued a statement of their own writing that “Big Walk was developed without an internal AI usage policy in place, and we consider that lack of policy a failure. We will work to have a more comprehensive policy going forwards.”

Local game devs have also had to grapple with AI usage at the local level. “We could tell some of the other pitches in the MGS were kind of generated…We wanted everyone’s ideas to be included, but if there was something that came up where someone was very obviously just generated an idea, we [were] like no, we’re just not gonna do that,” said Sophie Ducharme, writing lead on the game Beats and Brains by Met Game Studios. 

“I think that gaming, even though it’s virtual and it’s on computers, I think it’s a very human thing, and I think it’s a connection between the game creator and the player. And I think that the use of GenAI kind of just severs that like connection, and just makes it a little bit more of like a cold, impersonal experience,” she said.

Stanislaw Jackowski’s feelings are less strong when it comes to using AI. “Me personally, not as firm a stance as some of the others in my club. I think particularly the artists; they’re the most outspoken against it… I think even people in a discipline you might sort of expect, like maybe programming, for example. You might think maybe they’d welcome AI as a tool to help me get stuff done faster, but even them, they’re not really into it. No one’s really for it.” Jackowski is a game design lead at Met Game Studios. 

Jackowski said he can see uses for AI when generating ideas. “Apart from that, though, I think any sort of official incorporation of it into the process of coming up with designs for games is probably off the table, I would think, at least for the club. As far as professional studios go, I don’t know what they get up to. They’ll probably end up using it for programming, that sort of thing. But as far as my department for our club, we have no interest in it.” 

The IGF jurors say their statement was released to push back on the “inevitability” of AI’s use in creative industries. It also coincides with an increase in AI skepticism in the audience at large. According to the Angus Reid Institute, 67 per cent of Canadians describe their view of AI as “negative” or “critical” despite an increase in usage. 

“I think of video games as an art form in and of themselves,” said Ducharme. “I don’t know if I’ve played any games recently that have been outed, I guess outed, quote unquote, as like using AI. But I probably, if it was for something big, like the writing or the art, I probably would stop playing.”

You may also like