AI disclosure statement: AI was used to transcribe the interviews.

Listen to the whole story here:
You Can See Everything claimed the number one spot at the box office over Halloween weekend, according to Box Office Mojo, raking in a cumulative $63.9 million across Canada and the U.S. Since then, numbers have only risen; as it’s reported, the film has garnered $89 million in its first month after release.
Historically, such films have caught the eye of many viewers. For example, The Menendez Brothers, the 2024 documentary that followed Lyle and Erik Menendez as they spoke out after being convicted of murdering their parents, drew 22.7 million viewers during its premiere week, as reported by Netflix. Similarly, Fahrenheit 9/11, the 2004 documentary investigating the Bush administration’s response to the Sept. 11 attacks, grossed $119 million domestically and $222 million worldwide throughout its theatrical run, according to Box Office Mojo.
A Canadian example of this phenomenon is Trainwreck: Mayor of Mayhem, the 2025 documentary that analyzed the 2013 crack cocaine scandal of Toronto’s former mayor, Rob Ford. The film garnered 6.4 million viewers in its first week, placing sixth on Netflix’s weekly top 10.
All of these documentaries are based on controversial events and charismatic characters who received lots of public attention and media coverage. Why are these scandals so captivating to audiences?
“[A part of it] is the human tendency to be attracted to negativity. It’s almost counterintuitive why people would want to hear stories about dishonesty or, in some cases, violence,” said Patricia Sanchez, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto (U of T) whose research includes the influence of media consumption on beliefs and media portrayals of psychological science.
Another possibility for this is the chance to be informed of the different kinds of harm there is in the world.
“If we can see others getting duped or falling victim to deception, then maybe on some level we think that we are better armed against this kind of deception in our own lives,” said Sanchez.
The fact that these events had previously been extensively reported on doesn’t seem to deter the public from wanting to follow their timeline in film form, even if the end result is known.
“We don’t necessarily need to be hooked by [the ending]; we also want to know the process. This also explains why movies about World War II are so popular,” said Sanchez.
In the case of You Can See Everything, the known outcome is that Holmes goes to jail (she’s in a federal prison in Texas till 2030), but that may be the least interesting aspect of her story.
“There’s a promise of some kind of access [to Holmes] that’s going to tell us more than we already found out through traditional reporting,” said Charlie Keil, a U of T professor of film studies.
However, the fervour this documentary has incited can also be attributed to the involvement of Nathan Fielder in its creation.
“My interest came from the director. [I’d watched] some of his other projects like Nathan for You, so this really piqued my [curiosity],” said Gopigan Mohanarajan, a fifth-year sociology student at TMU.
In this project, Fielder, a Canadian filmmaker, walks the line between reality and fiction by including re-enactments of instances that weren’t captured on camera. To do this, he enlisted the help of actors Christopher Abbott in the role of Billy Evans, Holmes’ long-term romantic partner, and Amanda Seyfried as Holmes herself. This goes a step above breaking the fourth wall, as Seyfried reprised her role as Holmes after having played her in the 2022 miniseries The Dropout.
“It’s just a very activist sense of what the limits of a documentary filmmaker’s intervention is,” said Keil.
And although this may call into question the credibility of the film, it’s not something that is necessarily bad.
“If one of your questions as a viewer is, can this documentary be objective? He’s all but saying in the film, ‘No,’ but he’s also not trying to hide that, so it just makes you question even more if you are really seeing everything [as the title suggests],” said Keil.

Yet another reason people may be compelled to watch these types of films is the mystique behind scandalous cases.
“Humans in general are not comfortable with ambiguity. We don’t like to leave things open-ended,” said Sanchez.
In You Can See Everything, this is presented by highlighting Holmes’ perception of truth and whether she truly believes her own claims.
“People kind of want to decide whether she’s fully guilty or not, and anything in between [leads to] that discomfort area,” said Sanchez.
The interest in this specific documentary also lies in the curiosity to understand Holmes as a person and the possible motivations for her crimes, and whether it lines up with preconceived notions.
To explain this, Sanchez described stereotype incongruency, which is what happens when one remembers certain details about someone because they are inconsistent with preconceived stereotypes they had about that person or a group they belong to.
“I think with Elizabeth Holmes, there might be a case where there’s lots of elements that might be incongruent with people’s stereotypes [of] a pretty, smart woman… Data shows that young women tend to be stereotyped as kind and caring, so when you learn that something doesn’t fit the mould, it tends to grab people’s attention,” she said.
This could also translate as sympathy for Holmes, according to Mohanarajan.
“I felt a bit of sympathy… I noticed that the husband seemed in control of what she was doing, like running a Twitter page in her name and making controversial tweets…There seems to be a very interesting dynamic between what she wants and what the husband envisions.”
However, this didn’t shift Mohanarajan’s inherent feelings regarding Holmes’ actions. “It didn’t really change the fact that she scammed a bunch of people.”
