Home Editor's Picks 2Maple Leafs Still Winless in November

Maple Leafs Still Winless in November

The Toronto Maple Leafs blew a 3-0 lead to the LA Kings, extending their losing streak to eight games.

by Ethan Clarke

Toronto maple leaf fans line up outside Scotiabank arena
Toronto Maple Leafs fans line up outside Scotiabank Arena ahead of the Leafs’ matchup against the Los Angeles Kings on Nov. 19, 2026 (OTR/Ethan Clarke).

Listen to the whole story here:

The Toronto Maple Leafs remain winless in November, going eight games without a victory, including a historic six-game homestand where the Leafs went 0-6-0 without recording a single point, becoming only the second team in NHL history to do so, joining the 1970-71 Los Angeles Kings, who did not make the playoffs that season.

The Leafs’ play this season has surprised many fans after the team made a flurry of changes in the offseason.

The Leafs brought in new management, appointing John Chayka as general manager and Mats Sundin as executive adviser along with a new head coach, Jim Hiller. The roster also saw many changes, most notably the addition of  first overall pick Gavin McKenna. The Leafs also acquired defenceman Darren Raddysh in a sign-and-trade and, just before the start of the regular season, made a blockbuster trade to acquire Kirill Marchenko.  

“On paper, I was excited. I thought there was a buzz with the change in leadership,” said Erin McLean, a self-described lifelong Leafs fan who has supported the team for 25 years.

“And then the rug was pulled out from underneath me.”

During the historically poor homestand, HockeyViz founder Micah Blake McCurdy saw a pattern that has haunted the Leafs throughout the season.

His season-wide analysis found that Toronto’s chance generation was approximately 5 per cent below league average when tied and 18 per cent below when trailing by one. However, when trailing by two, the team generated more offence, climbing to about 14 per cent above average.

McCurdy said, “I’ve seen that before where some teams are like, okay, we’re going to tighten up even though we’re down because we can play tighter defensively.”

McCurdy said he suspects the boost in offence when trailing by two could be partly due to the Leafs playing captain Auston Matthews more. He pointed out that Matthews has been quite the impact player this season, leading the team in both goals and assists. 

Leafs head coach Jim Hiller has faced criticism amid the losing streak and McCurdy said the team’s struggles may be related to coaching decisions. But whether the approach is intentional, “It’s his business to fix it.”

The Leafs’ offence has struggled throughout the losing streak, the team scoring just 15 goals in eight games. McCurdy noted that Toronto has struggled to generate quality shots in the slot and lacks players capable of moving the puck up the ice.

The absence of star winger Kirill Marchenko, who recorded 14 points in his first 14 games, has only added to those struggles. McCurdy identified Marchenko as one of the Leafs’ few effective puck carriers.

a man wearing a #16 Mitch Marner jersey walks past legends row outside scotiabank arena
A passerby walks past Legends Row outside Scotiabank Arena before Toronto’s game against the Los Angeles Kings on Nov. 19. (Ethan Clarke/On The Record)

The struggles haven’t been limited to its offence; its defence has also been subpar according to McCurdy.

Throughout the entire homestand, the Leafs’ top-pairing defence of Darren Raddysh and Jake McCabe had been outscored 7-2 despite expected-goals data indicating only a 4-3 deficit against them.

Expected goals in hockey is an analytics metric that estimates the quality of scoring chances based on how likely shots are to become goals.

Michael Schuckers, a professor at UNC Charlotte’s School of Data Science, found this concerning from the top pair.

“You still want your best pairing to be outperforming the other team’s best, right? I mean, best on best. You hope to win those.”

But Schuckers said he thought this 7-2 scoreline was a bit harsh on the pairing. “I think probably they were a little bit unlucky on that homestand.”

Schuckers explained that expected goals are meant to be more of a predictor of future performance, and he would guess that, in the future, they would most likely fall into that four-to-three deficit.

One hot talking point throughout the Leafs season has been the team’s goaltending. The Leafs signed veteran goalie Sergei Bobrovsky to a three-year, $21-million deal. But Bobrovsky’s start to his Leafs career hasn’t gone to plan. Bobrovsky has recorded just three wins in 14 games and has an .874 save percentage.

“To see an established goalie come in and feel energized that now he’s finally on your team, but he seems like, I don’t know, out of place, hasn’t seemed himself,” said McLean.

But McCurdy said he thinks the criticism of the goaltending has been a bit harsh; at the time of the interview, his models showed the Leafs’ goaltending has allowed 69 goals on 68 expected goals, suggesting their goaltending has performed as expected given the quality of shots they’ve faced.

“They put ordinary goaltending out six times against better than ordinary goaltending,” said McCurdy.

But despite what the numbers say, McLean wants to see more from the goaltending.

“We needed strong goaltending to help us eke out wins. And they’re costing us wins at this point.”

McLean attended the Leafs’ 4-0 loss to the New Jersey Devils. She described a home atmosphere that disappeared as the game went along and the Devils’ lead grew larger.

“There was no excitement, no buzz … there was nothing to cheer about.”

McCurdy sees Toronto as a bottom-half NHL team that could use significant improvement, whether through rethinking strategies, young players developing, or new players who can carry the puck and make passes.

But McLean would like to see a sense of urgency within the team. “It seems like losing is status quo and that’s okay. And it’s extremely frustrating.”

You may also like